|
Medi- Minutes
NH Surrenders!
Medicaid Recovery Settlement
May Signal Trend for Other
States
In a recent settlement that interrupts a string of decisions in favor
of aggressive Medicaid estate recovery, the State of New Hampshire was
forced to change its estate recovery practices, to refund up to $5 million
that had been wrongfully recovered, and to release and discharge approximately
$20 million in real estate liens and mortgage deeds.
Federal Medicaid law requires states to recover Medicaid expenses from
the estates of recipients who were over 55 when they received long-term
care assistance. In states where the definition of "estate" has been expanded
to include jointly held property, the state may attempt to recover expenses
from the estate of the Medicaid recipient’s surviving spouse. But such
recovery must take place after the death of the recipient’s surviving spouse
or dependent or disabled children. Several states have been successful
in the past year with aggressive tactics against the estates of surviving
spouses.
But New Hampshire, which has not yet even expanded the definition of
"estate" to include jointly held property, crossed lines even those states
would not. New Hampshire’s Medicaid recovery practices clearly conflicted
with federal law:
-
Filing liens after the recipient’s death against real property partly owned
by the surviving spouse;
-
Demanding payment from the surviving spouse during his or her lifetime
before releasing Medicaid liens;
-
Refusing to limit Medicaid claims to the recipient’s ownership interest
in real property; and
-
Refusing to give notice and hearing either before or after the filing of
Medicaid liens.
The lawsuit (DesFosses v. Shumway, Case No. 97-CV-625B (D.N.H.))
was brought by six widows on December 12, 1997, and was settled on September
14, 1999. Under the settlement, New Hampshire agreed to
-
Pay back all money wrongfully recovered, with interest;
-
Stop placing liens on homes where the surviving spouse still resides;
-
Stop forcing the surviving spouse to pay Medicaid expenses of a deceased
recipient;
-
Stop recovering Medicaid expenses from a surviving spouse’s estate.
This settlement not only represents a victory for surviving spouses of
Medicaid recipients in New Hampshire, but also could trigger similar class
action suits against other states practicing aggressive Medicaid recovery.
Fortunately, South Carolina has not yet expanded the definition of "estate"
to include jointly held property and has not yet implemented abusive estate
recovery policies like those used in New Hampshire.
Source: The ElderLaw Report 2-2000
|